Tuesday, June 27, 2017

Even the devil can quote Scripture

Then the devil took (Jesus) to the holy city and placed him on the pinnacle of the temple, saying to him, “If you are the Son of God, throw yourself down; for it is written,

‘He will command his angels concerning you,’
    and ‘On their hands they will bear you up,
so that you will not dash your foot against a stone.’”

Jesus said to him, “Again it is written, ‘Do not put the Lord your God to the test.’”

Matthew 4:5-7



There is a lot of quoting of Bible passages going on in the world, and in the Church today.  People use the Bible as a crutch to convince others that one is right in his or her social or political position.  If someone tries to persuade you using a select Bible passage, remember this: even the devil quotes Scripture.  Here is the famous line from William Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice:

“The devil can cite Scripture for his purpose.
An evil soul producing holy witness
is like a villain with a smiling cheek,
a goodly apple rotten at the heart.
O, what a goodly outside falsehood hath!”


This is a good time for us to review Church teaching on the Sacred Scriptures.   The material below is largely taken from posts on this topic back in June of last year.

Popular language typically refers to the Scriptures as the Bible.  Scriptures literally means "the writings".  "Bible" is adapted from the Greek word "ta biblia" which means "the books".   They are pretty much synonyms.  The Catechism uses the collective word "Scripture" instead of "Scriptures".

Divine Revelation (God's revealing of himself) is transmitted, from one source, but in two distinct modes, Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition. The Catechism of the Catholic Church defines Sacred Scripture as
"the speech of God as it is put down in writing under the breath of the Holy Spirit." (Paragraph 81).   The word "speech" here is important.  Revelation is indeed God speaking to us; it is not just showing us, or demonstrating something, but more than that, desiring a connection with us.  In order for God to communicate with us, and establish that connection, it would make sense that He would choose to speak human words.

However, God did not choose to just open the skies and speak from the heavens.  He chose, rather, to speak through human beings like you and me, in the pages of Sacred Scripture. 

Why did He choose to do it this way, and not more openly?   This is only my speculation, but I think that it has something to do with the reality that we are more open to hearing something, and comprehending it better, especially when it comes to Divine realities, if it comes in the course of everyday speech, rather than if it was thunderous and loud.  We would not be "afraid" of what was said.   Furthermore, I think only a select few people, saints, would be able to understand if God spoke as He would normally communicate.  By communicating in human words, He can reach more people, who may not be in as tune with heavenly realities.  God speaking in human words, the Catechism says beautifully, is the
"condescension of his goodness" (p.101).

So Scripture is God speaking in human words. 
What is he speaking?  He is speaking His Word, Jesus.  As the Catechism says in paragraph 181, "Through all the words of Sacred Scripture, God speaks only one single Word, his one Utterance in whom he expresses himself completely."   Ultimately, everything in Scripture points to Jesus as the Way, the Truth, and the Life. 

But what about the Holy Spirit? Well, we can only be led to Jesus in the power of the Holy Spirit.  The Holy Spirit is the inspiration and interpreter of Sacred Scripture.

In order to understand Scripture in accordance with the Spirit, three criteria must be followed:

1) There are different forms of literature in the Bible, from different time periods, but they all form one
unity.  Any understanding of one particular passage must take into account the unity of the entire book.

2) The Scriptures must be read within the
Tradition of the Church.  The Church came before the Bible.  Yes, some of the books were written before the Church began, but they were not declared to be part of the Canon of Scripture until after the Church was founded by Our Lord.   "Canon" means "list of books".  In this case, it was which books were inspired, and which were not.  (We will speak more on the canon later.)
3) When reading Scriptures, we must be attentive to the analogy of the faith.   This means we must read the Scriptures in light of what the Church teaches about faith and morals.

The Church teaches there are two "senses" of Scripture, the
literal and the spiritual.   The literal refers to the literal words on the page.   The spiritual sense refers not to the literal text, but to the spiritual realities they point to.

The spiritual sense can be further subdivided into three more types.  The first is
allegorical.   Something can be a figure of something else.  Most of the time, when speaking of this sense of Scripture, it means something being a figure of Christ and the Church.  For example, the bronze serpent tied to the pole (Numbers 21:8-9) is a symbol of Christ on the Cross.  The second is moral.   The words in Scripture should lead us to act a certain way.  For example, in giving the Ten Commandments to Moses to give to the Israelites, or Paul waxing lyrical on love to the Corinthians, God is also inspiring us to live in moral ways.  Finally, there is the anagogical sense.   The word means "leading"; Catholic theology takes that to mean here "leading to heaven".   Some things in the Scriptures point directly toward heavenly realties; for example, Jerusalem can be viewed as a symbol of the Church triumphant.

Speaking of the Church, only in the Catholic Church is there a teaching office that is charged with giving an authentic interpretation of Sacred Scripture.  This office is called the
Magisterium.   The magisterium is the teaching office of the Church, which is the bishops in communion with the Bishop of Rome, the Pope.   We will probably speak more about the Magisterium in a future post, as interpretation of Scripture is not its only function.  However, it is an important one, and how so glad I am for this gift, that I don't have to interpret Scripture for myself.   Especially considering the times we live in, I am so grateful for the gift of the Magisterium, and I find myself thanking God for it almost daily now.  Our Lord says to his apostles in Luke 10:16, "He who hears you, hears me."  The apostolic teaching tradition lives in the Magisterium of the Church.

You may be thinking now, "Well, didn't we just say the Holy Spirit is the interpreter of Scripture?"  Yes, we did.   However, one person could easily say well the Spirit says this, and another could say the Spirit says that.  Yes, the Spirit is the interpreter of Scripture, but who gives the interpretation?  Who is the voice of the Holy Spirit?   If there is a dispute, where do we turn to?   Protestants have nowhere to turn to.  Other religions have nowhere to turn to.  Only Catholics do.  Catholics have the Magisterium, who the Catechism says has
"the task of giving an authentic interpretation of the Word of God, whether in its written form or in the form of Tradition." (paragraph 85) 

A Catholic in joyful humility will defer to the teaching authority of the Church to help him or herself better understand those difficult passages in Scripture, or seeming contradictions within the words of Scripture.   The Magisterium, rather than being a burden, is a tremendous liberator for us, and safeguard, to keep us all united, and centered, in our never ending desire to drink deeply of the words of Sacred Scripture.  Only the Magisterium can prevent us from going to extremes or off into our world of private interpretation, of which we can see throughout history the devastating results of.  Let us thank God daily for this gift, and know, as we read Scripture, that the Church is always there as a caring mother, helping us to understand what is being spoken to us.   Like our mothers helped us learn to read, Holy Mother Church helps us learn to read Scripture, but not just to read it, but to hear what God speaks to us through the pages of the Bible.

We mentioned earlier the
canon of Sacred Scripture.  The definition of canon is a collection or list of sacred books accepted as genuine.  In the early days of the Church, the Church Fathers had to decide which writings taught false or incomplete ideas of God, which taught good or noble ideas, but were not necessarily inspired, and finally, which books were inspired by God, the speech of God. 

It is important to note that the final canon was not determined until four centuries after the death of Our Lord.  It is not just like a book dropped out of the sky right at the beginning of the Church.  There was time in the Church without the Bible as we know it.   There was Tradition, and there was Scripture, but there was not a canon of Scripture, or what we now call the Bible.  The inspired works, however, were being read at liturgy.  This is critically important.  The first use of Scripture was not for private meditation, but for use at public liturgy.  We must realize that anew today. There is nothing wrong with private mediation and prayer with the Bible, but the primary forum in which we engage, and get the most out of the written Word of God, is at liturgy, in the public worship of the Church.  The words of Scripture are meant to be lived at the heart of the Church, which means they have their most power when they are read and heard at her celebration of the liturgy, where She is most Herself, because only there, does She celebrate and makes present the events of our salvation.  Catholic biblical authors such as Scott Hahn have written beautifully on the connection between Scripture and the liturgy, and I encourage you to read them.  We have spoken about liturgy in a previous post or two, and may speak about it more.

The complete list, or canon, includes 46 books in what is called the Old Testament, and 27 in what is called the New Testament. 

The Old Testament is the gradual revelation of God before He revealed Himself fully in the person of Jesus Christ in the New.  Through the trials, tribulations, victories, and defeats of God's chosen people Israel, whom he selected to begin his Revelation through, God gradually revealed Himself. 
 
The New Testament reveals the full revelation of God in His Son, Our Lord Jesus Christ.  At this chosen time in history, God fully revealed Himself.  Why this time, and not another time?  Perhaps we will only know in heaven why 2000 years ago in the Middle East was the perfect time for God to become man.  The bottom line, for us, now, though, is that He did. 

The New Testament's center object is Jesus Christ, and the beginnings of His Church.  It is my contention if the New Testament was simply about Jesus, it would only have included the 4 Gospels, and not the Acts of the Apostles, and the various letters that follow.

Speaking of the Gospels, they are considered the heart of the Scriptures, because it is from them that we learn and hear the most about Jesus, who is the full revelation of the Father.   The Gospels did not come at the same time as Jesus, but were written several decades after His Resurrection.  They were written based on the life of Jesus, but also based on the experience of his first followers, empowered by the Holy Spirit, who began an oral tradition.

Despite the fact that the New Testament contains the fullness of God's self-revelation, and the Old Testament does not, it is important to note that the Church still considers the books of the Old Testament as inspired by God because in them, the realities of the New Testament are preconfigured. If one reads the Old Testament with the
allegorical sense (one of the "senses" we spoke of moments ago.)   For example, Adam preconfigures Christ.   Eve preconfigures Mary.   Noah's ark preconfigures the Church. The serpent tied to the staff preconfigures the Cross. 
Having said that, the books of the Old Testament have their own intrinsic value as it tells the love story of God for His people, and gives us many valuable life lessons today (i.e. the 10 Commandments).  Also, the New Testament really cannot be understood in its fullness without the light of the Old.

Because of this, at Sunday Mass, we usually see the First Reading from the Old Testament tie somehow into the Gospel reading; if you pay attention you will see the connection.   For example, on a Sunday last June, the 1st Reading from the Prophet Zechariah spoke of the house of David looking "on him whom they have pierced”, and in the Gospel reading from Luke, Jesus said he must be "killed".  The prophet's words preconfigure what would happen to Jesus many years later. 

There is a unity to the Old and New Testament.  There is a unity to Scripture.  There is a Magisterium who can faithfully give interpretation to Scripture, based on the Holy Spirit, who is the authentic interpreter of Scripture.  Scripture is primarily for use at liturgy, but it can also be read on an individual level for personal spiritual nourishment, as long as the person reading asks the same Holy Spirit for wisdom and understanding. This is all the beautiful Catholic vision of Scripture.  


If Scripture does not mean much to you now, or overwhelms you, then ask the Holy Spirit for inspiration to help you be able to engage it more fully.  Do not go at it alone.  Hear and listen to God's Word with fellow believers at liturgy.  Seek the wisdom of the Church for questions on interpretation of this or that passage.  At the same time, however, do not get bogged down in one or two specific lines of Scripture.  The totality and unity of the entire book is more important.

May we grow in love for the written Word of God, the Sacred Scriptures, as a whole, and in seeing the love and unity of God revealed in those pages, may there be love and unity in our lives, as well.  Let us not isolate passages from the Bible as many do today, and let us certainly not isolate ourselves from the authentic interpreter of Scripture, the Magisterium of the Catholic Church.


Saint Joseph, pray for us.


No comments:

Post a Comment